NEW YORK: A federal judge told federal prosecutors Thursday that the government must permit a man jailed on terrorism charges access to religious materials describing an important figure in Muslim history even if passages advocate violence because similar violent texts in the Bible would never be banned from distribution in jails.
Judge Colleen McMahon made the statement as she presided over a hearing where Mohammad Baqer Saad Dawood Al-Saadi, a dual Iranian-Iraqi national, repeatedly tried to speak directly to her, leading US marshals to usher him quickly out of the courtroom at one point.
His lawyer, Andrew Dalack, said the government had denied Al-Saadi access to a biography of a man who lived 1,300 years ago and who McMahon described as a “seminal figure in Muslim” history.
Assistant US Attorney Jeffrey Coyle said the materials sent by Al-Saadi’s family contained passages that “justifies the blood revenge of enemies.”
McMahon stopped just short of issuing a ruling from the bench that religious texts do not pose a threat to the special administrative measure that severely limit Al-Saadi’s communications with the outside world. But she made her opinions clear.
“Excuse me,” she said, interrupting the prosecutor at one point. “There are passages in the Bible that could be read the same way.”