Prof Peter Hindmarsh played key role in conviction of two Birmingham parents whose son died after diabetes episode
A doctor who gave expert evidence that helped to convict Lucy Letby, and who was barred during the trial from treating patients, was then instructed as an expert witness in another prosecution.
The Guardian revealed this week that Prof Peter Hindmarsh was excluded from clinical practice in March 2023, during the main trial of Letby, by his employer, University College London hospitals trust (UCLH). The jury, who five months later convicted Letby of the murder of seven babies, were never told.
Among the reasons for UCLH’s decision was that Hindmarsh’s advice to child patients relating to insulin was not considered safe. The restriction on Hindmarsh’s working practices has cast further doubt on the prosecution’s case against the nurse, who is serving 15 whole-life sentences.
Hindmarsh went on to produce a crucial expert report in August 2023 that the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) used to support a case against two Birmingham parents, Damion and Tamara Thomas, who were accused of neglecting their son Joshua, 12, before he died.
Doctors had found that Joshua had suffered from his first episode of diabetes, which became critical and was a cause of his death on 10 December 2022.