📰 Newspapers

NY woman’s 20-year apartment fight continues after court rejects landlord’s commercial lease claim

NY woman’s 20-year apartment fight continues after court rejects landlord’s commercial lease claim

A landlord's attempts to reclaim a Manhattan apartment are hindered due to ongoing claims about rent stabilization. E. Terese Carpenter has resided in the unit for over 20 years, despite the existence of a commercial lease. The appeals court identified unresolved issues regarding the actual use of the apartment and the landlord's awareness of the situation.

A New York landlord's attempt to recover possession of an apartment has suffered a setback after an appeals court allowed a long-running dispute over rent-stabilisation protections to proceed. The case centres on E. Terese Carpenter, who says she has lived in a Manhattan apartment for more than 20 years, even though the landlord required a company she owned to sign a commercial lease describing the space as being used exclusively for business. In a November 19, 2026 decision, available on Justia, the New York Supreme Court's Appellate Division, First Department, upheld a lower court's refusal to grant the landlord summary judgment, finding that there were unresolved questions about the apartment's actual residential use and the landlord's knowledge of it. The ruling in 38 E. 64th St., LLC v. Nile, Inc. allows Carpenter's rent-stabilisation claims to continue.Landlord sought to recover the Manhattan apartmentThe dispute involves an apartment in a building at 38 East 64th Street in Manhattan. The landlord, 38 East 64th Street, LLC, rented the unit to Nile, Inc., a company owned by Carpenter, beginning in or around 2006. Although the premises were an apartment, the landlord required Nile to enter into a commercial lease stating that the space would be used exclusively for business purposes. The building's certificate of occupancy, however, permitted only residential use.Carpenter maintained that she had…

In brief

A New York landlord's attempt to recover possession of an apartment has suffered a setback after an appeals court allowed a long-running dispute over rent-stabilisation protections to proceed. Nile, Inc. allows Carpenter's rent-stabilisation claims to continue.Landlord sought to recover the Manhattan apartmentThe dispute involves an apartment in a building at 38 East 64th Street in Manhattan.

This is the opening of the story, shared with credit to The Times of India — World. The rest of the report — with every detail — continues on the publisher’s website.

Continue reading at The Times of India — World ↗

Cookie settings

Choose which cookies we may use. You can change this at any time from Cookie settings in the footer. Details of each cookie are in the Cookie Policy.

Strictly necessary

Needed for sign-in, security, payments and remembering these choices. Always on.

Preferences

Remember settings such as dark mode.

Analytics & performance

Help us count visits, understand which pages, devices and countries our readers use, and measure how well the site performs – anonymous and aggregated.

Advertising & marketing

Lets advertising partners show and personalise adverts, measure impressions, clicks and visits, prevent ad fraud and pay us – this is how the free site is funded.

🔔 News notifications

Get headlines from NewsHub on this device — even when the site is closed.

You can switch this off at any time. Works on Android, Windows, Mac and Linux browsers; on iPhone/iPad add the site to your Home Screen first.