It was, according to Queensland Coalition senator Susan McDonald, a "most unsatisfactory" mistake.
The Senate was interrogating the federal government's plans for a domestic gas reservation scheme, and bitter rivals had accidentally been lumped together to appear at the same time.
In one corner was Dan Clark, the head of giant east coast gas exporter Australia Pacific LNG (APLNG).
In the other was Tracey Winters, chief strategy officer of Australia's second-biggest oil and gas company, Santos, the operator of a neighbouring plant on Queensland's Curtis Island known as Gladstone LNG (GLNG).
Mr Clark pointed out that APLNG had supplied the equivalent of four years of the eastern states' entire domestic gas demand since starting operations 10 years ago.
By contrast, and in none-too-subtle terms, he said, "another" player had taken almost as much gas out of the domestic market.
"Since the startup of our LNG facility, APLNG has delivered over 1,900 petajoules to the domestic market," Mr Clark told the Senate's Economics Legislation Committee.
"But for every four of those petajoules APLNG has contributed to Australia, another exporter on the east coast has taken three petajoules back out."
"In the evidence that we just heard, APLNG is acting purely in its commercial interests," she argued.
That the two were exchanging home truths is testament to how heated the debate about…


