Surrogates should receive greater compensation and policies should be nationally consistent, under a proposed overhaul of the system.
Under the changes, intended parents would be legally recognised from birth, if a domestic arrangement was approved before conception.
The federal government says it will consider the recommendations alongside the states and territories.
Surrogates would be entitled to greater financial compensation for the impacts of pregnancy and childbirth under sweeping changes proposed by the country's law reform body.
The wide-ranging final report from the Australian Law Reform Commission (ALRC) found Australia's patchwork of state and territory laws made surrogacy unnecessarily difficult, were driving parents overseas, could leave surrogates financially worse off and did not adequately safeguard the rights of children.
As part of its 47 recommendations, it said there should be one nationally consistent surrogacy framework overseen by a regulator and proposed that intended parents be recognised as legal parents from birth.
"Good surrogacy laws should do two things: enable people to form families through surrogacy where it can be undertaken responsibly; and provide effective safeguards against exploitation and harm. Our current laws do not achieve either aim," ALRC Justice Mordy Bromberg said.
"Instead, they drive Australians to pursue overseas surrogacy arrangements, which can expose children, surrogates, and intended parents to great risk of harm and exploitation."