Directly across the street from the about-to-be-blue U.S. Capitol, Election Day at the Supreme Court meant only another morning of oral arguments. And the day’s big case, although ostensibly about state aid to religious schools, carries echoes of the larger battle over how we envision pluralist democracy.First, some background. Then we’ll get to democracy.St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy is the latest in a line of cases where the justices have been called upon to balance important principles of law against the tenets of religions. Often the cases involve, as this one does, anti-discrimination law. Here, the law in question supplies funding to preschools, including religious preschools, as long as they agree to serve all comers without regard to, among other things, sexual orientation and gender identity. The Catholic preschools require all parents to agree that they will uphold the tenets of the faith, including, of course, on issues of sexuality.
Democracy needs room for religious difference
Democratic societies function best when they accommodate disagreement rather than demand conformity.
In brief
Directly across the street from the about-to-be-blue U.S. And the day’s big case, although ostensibly about state aid to religious schools, carries echoes of the larger battle over how we envision pluralist democracy.First, some background. Here, the law in question supplies funding to preschools, including religious preschools, as long as they agree to serve all comers without regard to, among other things, sexual orientation and gender identity.
This is the opening of the story, shared with credit to The Japan Times. The rest of the report — with every detail — continues on the publisher’s website.
Continue reading at The Japan Times ↗