A sample of discoloured water from a Sandy Bay home has tested above guideline levels for lead and manganese.
TasWater had previously told a resident the water was "safe to drink".
Health authorities say harm is unlikely from limited consumption, though TasWater is reviewing its messaging.
Testing of viscous, orange water that Tasmania's water authority had told a customer was safe to drink has returned levels of heavy metals above drinking water guidelines.
Two weeks ago, Sandy Bay resident Emma Thornley turned the taps on in her house and found discoloured water coming out. It happened throughout the day.
A load of white clothing came out of the washing machine with dark orange stains while thick, orange water poured from the kitchen tap.
State water provider, TasWater, advised residents in the area at the time that emergency repairs were being carried out on a nearby burst water main, and that drinking water "may be discoloured and cloudy" but was "safe to drink".
Ms Thornley called TasWater to tell the authority her water did not appear safe to drink so that it could notify other customers.
"I actually asked her to guarantee on the recorded line if this water was safe and would not contain anything harmful like heavy metals," she said.