A Canadian couple who built a wooden deck beside their holiday cabin without obtaining the required written permission have won a legal battle to keep the structure after a British Columbia appeals court upheld a $5,000 damages award instead of ordering its removal. The November 13 decision in Valley’s Edge Park Ltd. v. Holden followed a dispute between the homeowners and the company overseeing their recreational resort. The British Columbia Court of Appeal’s judgment, its official case summary and reporting by Canadian Legal News provide details of the ruling. Moira and Denis Holden owned a property at Valley’s Edge Resort in Edgewater, British Columbia, where residents are required to seek approval before making certain improvements to their lots. The requirement is part of a registered building scheme that gives the resort administrator authority over construction and alterations. The couple had previously obtained permission for improvements to another property they owned at the resort. However, their relationship with the company’s president later deteriorated, and a disagreement over the proposed deck eventually reached the courts.How the dispute beganIn 2022, the Holdens approached the elected president of the strata council with their plans for the deck. They were informed that the council did not have the authority to approve the construction.
Appeals Ruling: Court upholds $5,000 award; deck stays, unauthorised builds still carry costs
Moira and Denis Holden, a couple from Canada, constructed an unapproved wooden deck next to their cabin. They contested a demand from Valley's Edge Park Ltd. to have it taken down. The British Columbia Court of Appeal decided to uphold a $5,000 damages judgment, rather than requiring the deck's removal, as it found no notable adverse effects on the neighboring properties.
In brief
A Canadian couple who built a wooden deck beside their holiday cabin without obtaining the required written permission have won a legal battle to keep the structure after a British Columbia appeals court upheld a $5,000 damages award instead of ordering its removal. Moira and Denis Holden owned a property at Valley’s Edge Resort in Edgewater, British Columbia, where residents are required to seek approval before making certain improvements to their lots.
This is the opening of the story, shared with credit to The Times of India — World. The rest of the report — with every detail — continues on the publisher’s website.
Continue reading at The Times of India — World ↗



