Dubai: When an AI system contributes to a wrong diagnosis, no single party automatically carries the blame. Dr Alawi Alsheikh-Ali, Director General of Dubai Health Authority, said responsibility depends on how the tool is used.
Speaking at the AI Retreat during Dubai Future Week, in a session titled “Past the Pilot”, the DHA chief answered the question many patients ask. If AI leads to a wrong diagnosis, who is to be held responsible?
Alsheikh-Ali named three candidates. The physician, the hospital that allowed the technology, and the company that built it. He then separated two scenarios. AI can act as a tool that assists a doctor, or it can act as the care provider itself. “I don’t think we’re there yet” on the second, he said.
Where AI assists, the physician carries responsibility. A human provides oversight and makes the final call. A defect in the product shifts some liability to the developer. A hospital that lets staff use AI without proper vetting, monitoring or training may share the burden. “It’s not a straightforward answer,” he said, but it is probably a shared responsibility.
Patients should know AI's role
He emphasized on how patients should know when AI plays a part in their diagnosis. He described two stories from the clinic that show why the answer is hard.