Mitchell Tenpenny brought a little Nashville to New York!
The country music star took over Mulcahy’s in Wantagh, New York, on Thursday night (November 19), delivering a high-energy performance packed with fan favorites, unexpected covers, and plenty of crowd sing-alongs.
Mitchell kept the party going with hits like “Drunk Me,” “Truth About You,” “We Got History,” and “Alcohol You Later,” showing off his powerful vocals and undeniable stage presence.
But the biggest surprises came when Mitchell was joined by his brother and bassist Joe Olmo for a nostalgic trip down memory lane!
The brothers switched things up with a trio of throwback covers, including Sugar Ray’s “Fly,” Montell Jordan’s “This Is How We Do It,” and Nelly’s “Ride Wit Me.” The unexpected genre switch had the crowd singing along to every word!
The 37-year-old singer also performed “Bigger Mistakes,” “Bucket List,” “Goner,” and “Speed of Light,” before closing out the night with a cover of Goo Goo Dolls’ “Iris.”
Between the country hits, nostalgic throwbacks, and nonstop energy, Mitchell turned the intimate Long Island venue into one big party!
Mitchell Tenpenny’s Mulcahy’s Set List (November 19, 2026)
To Us It Did
You Phase
Happy and I Hate It
Truck I Drove in High School
We Got History
Bigger Mistakes
Same Moon
Truth About You
Anything She Says




