Last week, more than 50 people gathered at a private home in New York City for an aliyah program. The organizers never publicly disclosed the time or location. Security concerns made secrecy necessary.Yet hours before the event, the local police precinct contacted the organizers to say officers would be stationed outside. By the time guests arrived, barricades were in place, a SWAT team was present, and the street had been closed to vehicle traffic.The police understood the risk and acted before they were asked. That should reassure New York's Jews. It should also disturb them.This is what Jewish life in America has become: even a private gathering about moving to Israel may require secrecy, barricades, and armed protection.Against this backdrop, Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced on November 16 that the NYPD's Strategic Response Group would be disbanded.The roughly 500-officer unit has handled rapid deployment, crowd control, and support for counterterrorism operations. Its officers will remain in the department, and some responsibilities will move to the Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau.Other duties will be divided among separate police units and a new civilian-led protest initiative focused on communication and de-escalation.Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch allegedly supports the plan and says it will not weaken public safety. Perhaps she is right. But Jewish New Yorkers should demand evidence, not assurances.The concern is not whether the…
Who will protect New York's Jews after Mamdani disbanded a key NYPD unit? - opinion
Separating responsibilities does not necessarily make the city less safe. Confusion does.
In brief
Last week, more than 50 people gathered at a private home in New York City for an aliyah program. The organizers never publicly disclosed the time or location. Security concerns made secrecy necessary.Yet hours before the event, the local police precinct contacted the organizers to say officers would be stationed outside. That should reassure New York's Jews.
This is the opening of the story, shared with credit to The Jerusalem Post. The rest of the report — with every detail — continues on the publisher’s website.
Continue reading at The Jerusalem Post ↗