The ABC can reveal a fifth Melbourne Cup was stolen from Flemington Racecourse several years before the series of heists during this year's Spring Racing Carnival.
Earlier this month, the 1948 Caulfield Cup was stolen from Caulfield Racecourse and later Makybe Diva's three Melbourne Cups were taken from Flemington.
Two men have been charged over the thefts, and during a court appearance this week it emerged a fourth replica cup had been stolen during the carnival.
Six Melbourne and Caulfield cups are missing, it can be revealed, as the Victoria Racing Club (VRC) comes under fire by racing insiders over cup carnival security measures.
The ABC can reveal that in addition to four Melbourne Cups and one Caulfield Cup stolen in the recent heists during the peak of this year's racing carnival, the 1973 Melbourne Cup, which was stolen from Flemington several years ago, has never been found.
The late jockey Frank Reys became the first Indigenous jockey to win the historic race with Australian thoroughbred gelding Gala Supreme.
Years after Reys' death from cancer in 1984, his family donated the cup to the VRC.
The ABC understands it was stolen from its display near the exclusive Committee Room at Flemington Racecourse, but the exact date of the theft remains unclear.