Before they were enemies, Jacob and Esau were brothers. Before there was deception, exile, hatred, and fear, they shared a single womb.We usually read their story as a struggle to determine which brother would inherit the future. But perhaps that reading is already a concession to tragedy. What if the future was meant to belong to both of them?A Divine plan brokenJacob and Esau were both the sons of Isaac and Rebekah, born into the family from which the Jewish people would emerge.God's original intention, I believe, was not that one should replace the other, but that each would have his role to play in the emerging nation. Jacob would embody the spiritual genius of Israel; Esau its courage, vitality, and ability to deal with the physical world. One would give the people its soul, the other its strength. Neither could fulfill its purpose alone.But the brothers failed each other. Misunderstanding gave way to deception; deception to resentment; resentment to separation. Esau was driven out of the Jewish story altogether, and eventually became its enemy. What should have been a partnership became a wound. Jewish history has been bleeding from it ever since.This leads to a possibility so disturbing that we hardly dare consider it. What if the Torah given to Moses at Sinai was already shaped by this disaster?…
Thoughts to ponder: The unfinished State of Israel and the need for Esau - opinion
Esau represents far more than military power. He also represents science, art, culture, music, discovery, and the capacity to shape the material world.
In brief
Before they were enemies, Jacob and Esau were brothers. Jacob would embody the spiritual genius of Israel; Esau its courage, vitality, and ability to deal with the physical world. Misunderstanding gave way to deception; deception to resentment; resentment to separation. Esau was driven out of the Jewish story altogether, and eventually became its enemy.
This is the opening of the story, shared with credit to The Jerusalem Post. The rest of the report — with every detail — continues on the publisher’s website.
Continue reading at The Jerusalem Post ↗